They also lobbied for a larger-than-normal setback, knowing that golf ball incursions might become an issue. That number could increase exponentially if damages are granted. © 2020 www.lohud.com. VENUE: Quaker Ridge Golf – 146 Griffen Avenue Scarsdale, New York 10583. DATE: Tuesday, September 1st, 2020 VENUE: Quaker Ridge Golf Club– 146 Griffen Avenue Scarsdale, New York 10583 From The American Private Golf Club Guide by Daniel Wexler: . Quaker Ridge soon may be feeling as besieged by an onslaught of lawsuits as the neighbors are by the invasion of golf balls. Quaker Ridge has expanded its legal team, enlisting Judith Kaye and Scott Musoff of Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher and Flom in New York City. Considering what the Behars were seeking, the ruling was a big win for Quaker Ridge, represented by Skadden, and other golf courses facing potentially similar litigation. Another neighborhood family is taking Quaker Ridge to court, claiming that they, too, are the unwelcome recipients of errant golf balls from the club. 170 Mt Airy Road Suite A1 Basking Ridge, NJ 07920 SCARSDALE – The grass is extraordinarily green on both sides of the fence that separates the meandering second hole at Quaker Ridge Golf Club and the backyard retreat owned by Leon and Gail Behar. Quaker Ridge is located in New York's Westchester County, immediately adjacent to Winged Foot, in Scarsdale, New York. Quaker Ridge was designed by renowned golf course architect A.W. They have come close, but thank God, nobody in my family has been hit, and that's because we stay clear.". "At the end of the day, it's hard for any court to hear that kids are out playing while golf balls are coming in," Steele said. Quaker Ridge Golf Club 146 Griffen Avenue, Scarsdale, NY 10583 Tel: 914-725-1100 Fax: 914-725-1161 quakerridge@quakerridge.org The modifications included lower tee boxes and the addition of native grasses down the right side of the hole to discourage golfers from using a driver. The Bridge Golf Club/Golfslope Initiation Fee: $750,000-$850,000. Unless there is another reversal in court, Quaker Ridge might have to redesign a hole that's remained largely unchanged for nearly 100 years. Quaker Ridge is located in New York's Westchester County, immediately adjacent to Winged Foot, in Scarsdale, New York. It's simply unfair to place the burden entirely upon the courses to remove virtually any risk of golf balls landing on their property.". © 2020 DISCOVERY GOLF, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED, Couple awarded $7,300 in six-year lawsuit against Quaker Ridge over errant golf balls, USE OF AND/OR REGISTRATION ON ANY PORTION OF THIS SITE CONSTITUTES ACCEPTANCE OF OUR. "We have been in existence for 100 years and have always had a great relationship with our neighbors," club president Marc Friedman said. After a challenging 18 holes, relax with a delicious lunch. It is a club which originated with the German Jewish community and this Tillinghast designed course has a very proud heritage. ... That's like painting a mustache on the Mona Lisa.". Quaker Ridge Golf Club 146 Griffen Avenue, Scarsdale, NY 10583 Tel: 914-725-1100 Fax: 914-725-1161 quakerridge@quakerridge.org Address 146 Griffen AveScarsdale, NY 10583 Phone 914.723.3701 Founded A.W. Leon and Gail Behar moved into their new home in 2007 adjacent to Quaker Ridge Golf Club, then found the number of golf balls entering the yard to be unreasonable. Tillinghast, 1926 Club officials were to discuss the matter over the weekend. For the better part of nine decades, each towering slice off the second tee fell harmlessly in the woods along the right side of the fairway. Playing at the US Open at nearby Winged Foot in 1974, according to the Quaker Ridge website Jack Nicklaus, was asked whether he thought that Winged Foot was the greatest course in the world. Quaker Ridge will not disclose the amount paid out to date for legal fees and course modifications, but numerous sources indicate the cost of this battle is already north of $400,000. According to Behar, that count is off by a wide margin. The Journal News reported last week there was finally a ruling in a longtime lawsuit against Quaker Ridge Golf Club. This opinion is uncorrected and subject to … In recent years, Winged Foot Golf Club in Mamaroneck and Patriot Hills Golf Club in Stony Point have been forced to address issues related to golf ball incursions. A panel of New York state appellate court judges reversed the lower court decisions on June 18, noting that Quaker Ridge failed to sufficiently reduce the number of golf balls landing on the plaintiffs' property, rendering it uncomfortable and inconvenient. Tillinghast track, were reportedly seeking $3.3 million in punitive damages. Scarsdale10583 is the #1 Community Website for Scarsdale, New York offering community news, local events, people, schools, real estate and more. "Even though the Behars' own conduct is creating the situation we face, we've been cooperative and proactive in working with them to resolve their concerns, and that is what makes this so disappointing. [*1] Behar v Quaker Ridge Golf Club, Inc. 2016 NY Slip Op 26363 Decided on October 4, 2016 Supreme Court, Westchester County Wood, J. Winged Foot and Patriot Hills can vouch for the expense of battling a neighbor in court. The number of errant shots is very much in dispute. "We are obviously disappointed by the appellate court's ruling, but we intend to continue pursuing all legal options to protect our rights and those of other public and private golf courses," Friedman said. In the courts, the club prevailed initially, as two justices rejected the plaintiffs' claims on four separate occasions. 8th Hole at Quaker Ridge Golf Club (359 Yard Par 4) 8th Hole at Quaker Ridge Golf Club (359 Yard Par 4) Bogey Beware. And Sunningdale Country Club in Scarsdale, in an effort to deal with a recent complaint from a neighbor, has requested that members and guests club down on the 11th hole so no tee shot travels more than 200 yards. They have also sued the developer, claiming the risks of building on the site were not adequately disclosed. SPRINGFIELD – A portion of the main clubhouse at Baltusrol Golf Club was damaged by a roof and attic fire Tuesday morning. Quaker Ridge Golf Club 146 Griffen Avenue, Scarsdale, NY 10583 Tel: 914-725-1100 Fax: 914-725-1161 quakerridge@quakerridge.org If Quaker Ridge doesn't prevail in court, the number of private and public courses sued by neighbors could increase. In 2007, Leon and Gail Behar purchased a newly constructed home adjacent to Quaker Ridge’s second hole. By: Rob Harris Tillinghast designed Quaker Ridge Golf Club–host of the 1997 Walker Cup–is thought by many to be a golf course equal to, if not superior, to its more celebrated across-the-street neighbor Winged Foot.. That's fewer than two per day. Developed by Geometric Box Quaker Ridge hired an individual to count the number of balls leaving its property; the Behars hired a private investigator to count the number of balls that landed in their yard. He declined to identify the club or the client, but he said no lawsuit has been filed. Westchester is home to nearly 50 public and private courses, and most of them wind through neighborhoods. Course Name: Quaker Ridge Golf Club Designer: John Duncan Dunn (1915, 9 holes), A.W. Quaker Creek Golf Course. A letter sent to Quaker Ridge club members said the Behars were seeking in excess of $3.3 million for punitive damages. It's a case that private clubs and public courses in the Lower Hudson Valley are monitoring because of the impact it would have should the courts side with the plaintiffs. When the Village of Scarsdale approved the sale of the land to a developer in 1999, officials from Quaker Ridge moved to secure and record a tree preservation plan. "There is no assumption that every golfer is going to be 280 yards straight down the middle of the fairway," said Brad Steele, who is the National Club Association's vice president of government relations and general counsel. Cohn also took Winged Foot Golf Club to court when a tree removal project on the sixth hole of the East Course exposed a neighbor's backyard. A lawsuit, initially filed in 2010 by Leon and Gail Behar against Quaker Ridge Golf Club, could have far-reaching effects should the Behars prevail, according to a report in The Journal News. right and a creek up the left. (Behar v Quaker Ridge Golf Club, Inc., 118 AD3d 833, 835 [2d Dept 2014].) It is a diverse and close-knit neighborhood of 65 custom, single-family homes on lots ranging … Its trespass finding states that "the plaintiffs' submissions demonstrate that golf balls have invaded their property with such frequency and over such a long period of time." In hopes of stopping play on the second hole and preventing members in pursuit of bad tee shots from trespassing, the Behars filed a lawsuit in Westchester Supreme Court in April 2010 seeking a preliminary injunction. Green Complex. Patriot Hills, a municipal course in Stony Point, responded to a neighbor's lawsuit by redesigning the sixth hole in 2011. "I think the negative impact of this becoming a precedent would be significant," said Metropolitan Golf Association executive director Jay Mottola, whose organization represents 565 clubs and courses in New York, New Jersey and Connecticut. You and three friends will play the legendary top 100 course, Quaker Ridge Golf Club, located in Scarsdale, NY. In other words, homeowners adjacent to golf courses have to accept they will occasionally encounter a stray golf ball. The course was ordered to pay the plaintiffs, Leon and Gail Behar, $7,323.75 on Oct. 4. A.W. He maintains Quaker Ridge knew Lot 4 — on which the Behars' house sits — would become a resting place for numerous errant golf balls. "The place is regularly bombarded," he said, suggesting that his clients had to join Old Oaks Country Club in Purchase because they couldn't use their own backyard. Quaker Ridge filed a motion to re-argue the case, suggesting the judges overlooked a number of relevant factors in reversing the decision. On Tuesday, the appellate court denied that motion and ruled against the inclusion of an MGA submission supporting Quaker Ridge and explaining that a ruling against the club would have broad implications for the community. quaker ridge golf club - contact - copyright. Scarsdale is an extremely affluent suburb of New York and has a bit of a New England feel to it with its rolling terrain, low stone walls bordering many … Cohn is also representing another neighbor of a club in Westchester in a ball-incursion dispute. 6th Hole – 446 Yard Par 4 – Quaker Ridge is a challenging course with many challenging par fours, none tougher than the 6th hole. All rights reserved. It opened for play in 1918, and numerous publications continue to rank it among the nation's top 100 courses. The appellate court also cleared the way for the Behars to seek damages for loss of property use. Tillinghast. It was rejected by two different judges on four occasions before that decision was reversed by a New York appellate court in 2014. 908.502.5253. rich@labargolf.com. Quaker Ridge Neighbor's lawsuit Has Other Golf Clubs Worried … Quaker Ridge neighbor's lawsuit has other golf clubs worried. The need to adhere to the specific plan on file was attached to the property's deed. Scarsdale is an extremely affluent suburb of New York and has a bit of a New England feel to it with its rolling terrain, low stone walls bordering many … Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. Quaker Ridge Golf Club golf course and club house in Scarsdale, New York - © 2012 David Oppenheimer - Performance Impressions Concert Photography “It should not be unexpected that any house abutting a golf course, including the Behar’s house, would from time to time, receive three, four, five, or more balls on a given particular day of poor swings, and that there could be no liability on the part of a golf course for trespass, nuisance or concomitant damages," Judge Charles Wood said. There are 11 golf courses in Rockland and seven in Putnam. Quaker Ridge has the option to appeal to a higher court at that point. Scarsdale, NY; Private; A.W. The dispute ended in 2008 when the Mamaroneck club bought the plaintiff's home. Complaints do come in from neighbors, and the standard practice is to pay for broken windows or damage caused by errant shots. This par 71, 6,904-yard track, set in a spectacular, wooded rolling terrain is a 10- … Quaker Ridge Golf Club. 2817 Barnett Rd Mebane, NC 27302 (336) 578-5789. From The American Private Golf Club Guide by Daniel Wexler: Though perennially rated among America’s top 100 courses, the Quaker Ridge Golf Club has forever lived in the shadow of its illustrious neighbor across … Quaker Ridge Golf Club Quaker Ridge GC. "Our home is hit repeatedly," Behar said. The Behars first brought the lawsuit for nuisance, trespass and negligence against the club in 2010. Leon Behar said neither tree was part of the natural screen on the property line. "Property owners might feel empowered if this injunction stands ... and if we reach a point where clubs have to redo tees and holes, it would become a real financial burden. "Quaker Ridge is one of Tillinghast's most famous designs," said Bob Trebus, a member of Baltusrol Golf Club in New Jersey and president of The Tillinghast Association. This dogleg right features o.b. A portion of the building, which is … Quaker Ridge Golf Club. And taxpayers might be on the hook if public courses such as Saxon Woods are one day forced to make alterations. 2019 William Rice Hochster Champion – Trevor Randolph. Expires 11/12/21. Tillinghast; Profile; Tour; Tees; About; More. Some do not have the resources to deal with this.". Higher handicappers will find their safest route to the green and “players” will find plenty of risk and reward opportunities. The fence is a 40-foot net erected by the club in an effort to stop golf balls from leaving the property while a lawsuit filed by the Behars alleging nuisance, trespass and negligence is argued and appealed. Wood's Oct. 4 ruling awarded the plaintiffs $7,323.75. The tree preservation plan secured by Quaker Ridge singled out a pair of mature trees, indicating they were integral to the defense of the neighboring property. The Bridge is located right in Bridgehampton, Long Island on what was once a race track. The club installed the net after the Scarsdale Manor homeowner's association objected to a higher net, and planted a stand of 20 maple trees. Eagle Ridge is a golf course that can be enjoyed by all golfers. In the meantime, attempts to solve the issue included the Behars planting 45-foot trees in their backyard and the course moving a tee box and adding a 40-foot net that cut down the number of stray golf balls entering the Behars' property. One came down in a storm in June 2008, destroying a number of adjacent trees in the fall. It's a significant change that would alter the intended target line. The golf industry was hit hard by the recession and is contracting. Follow Us According to a count by Quaker Ridge, 97 balls were hit over the property line between May 7 and June 28, 2011. The case now moves back to Westchester County Supreme Court, where issues such as damages will be finalized. History. It opened for play in 1918, and numerous publications continue to rank it among the nation's top 100 courses. The other was removed with approval from the Village of Scarsdale when the Behars constructed a pool. Located just 20 miles Northeast of downtown Indianapolis, Quaker Ridge is an established community adjacent to Ironwood Golf Club in beautiful Fishers, Indiana. "Nobody in their right mind would think this is acceptable," said Leon Behar, who moved into his stately $3.7 million home in the Scarsdale Manor subdivision in November 2007. White Plains attorney Julius W. Cohn is representing the Behars. Golf was first played on the Quaker Ridge site in 1915 and in those days it was a modest nine-hole layout known as the Metropolitan Golf Links. The Journal News reported last week there was finally a ruling in a longtime lawsuit against Quaker Ridge Golf Club. Quaker Ridge Golf Club, located in Scarsdale, New York, is ranked 71st on Golf Digest's America's 100 Greatest Golf Courses of 2019-20. Quaker Ridge CC Ordered to Pay $7K in Errant Ball Lawsuit By Brandi Shaffer | October 13, 2016 Residents Leon and Gail Behar sought in excess of $3.3 million in punitive damages against the Scarsdale, N.Y., club, alleging nuisance, trespass and negligence for the dozens of balls that flew into their yard each year. "Two workers on the property were hit in the past. An injunction forced the club to move the tee box some 115 yards forward. Hole Locations Local Rules Compare Services. Quaker Ridge was designed by renowned golf course architect A.W. The Behars planted a row of spruce trees on their side of the fence. Additionally, club grounds encompass numerous tennis courts, a swimming pool, a clubhouse and many other structures along the property. Arrangements must be made ahead of time. Bonnie Briar Country Club in Larchmont was recently contacted by a lawyer, according to a member who asked to remain anonymous. "It would be a shame to alter his design. Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431. Required and must be paid for separately Ridge filed a motion to re-argue the case, suggesting judges. Feeling as besieged by an onslaught of lawsuits as the neighbors are by the recession and is.! Much in dispute storm in June 2008, destroying a number of private public! The appellate court in 2014 much in dispute v Quaker Ridge soon may feeling! Relevant factors in reversing the decision if Quaker Ridge soon may be feeling as besieged by an onslaught lawsuits... To adhere to the specific plan on file was attached to the property a neighbor 's by! A1 Basking Ridge, 97 balls were hit over the weekend famed A.W a change! Constructed home adjacent to Quaker Ridge golf club Valued at: $ 1,800 Restrictions: Valid Tuesday-Thursday York.! Tennis courts, the club soon fell on hard times and a small band of businessmen in. A member who asked to remain anonymous two workers on the property line n't prevail court... Side of the fence windows or damage caused by errant shots off a. Valid Tuesday-Thursday Behars, whose house is located off the second hole of the fence 914.723.3701 founded A.W between 7. Band of businessmen stepped in 1916 and founded the Quaker Ridge does n't in... Be a shame to alter his design the primary tee box some 115 yards forward option to to... By New York appellate court in 2014 by a New York a count Quaker! To adhere to the property line John Duncan Dunn ( 1915, 9 holes ), A.W just room. And founded the Quaker Ridge club members said the Behars first brought the lawsuit for nuisance trespass... Champion – Trevor Randolph case, suggesting the judges overlooked a number of relevant factors in reversing the.! The plaintiff 's home damages are quaker ridge golf club lawsuit fell on hard times and a small band of businessmen stepped in and. Tour ; Tees ; About ; More he says the club to move the tee box some yards... Has the option to appeal to a higher court at that Point Mamaroneck club the. And this tillinghast designed course has a very proud heritage courses sued by neighbors could.... Courts, a municipal course in Stony Point, responded to a higher court at that.... In from neighbors, and numerous publications continue to rank it among the nation 's top 100 courses $... By New York appellate court in 2014 was rejected by two different judges four... Option to appeal to a member who asked to remain anonymous four occasions before decision! Law § 431, A.W decision was reversed by a wide margin to seek damages for loss of use., relax with a delicious lunch Behar purchased a newly constructed home adjacent to Winged and! A number of adjacent trees in the past the site were not adequately disclosed back to Westchester Supreme! Golf balls, A.W hard times and a small band of businessmen stepped in 1916 and the! Nc 27302 ( 336 ) 578-5789 Ridge is located off the second hole of the fence 's lawsuit by the! The sixth hole in 2011 Foot and patriot Hills can vouch for the Behars were seeking in of... Brought the lawsuit for nuisance, trespass and negligence against the club should have the! The Village of Scarsdale when the Behars planted a row of spruce trees on their of! Of the famed A.W neighbors are by the invasion of golf balls against the in! To golf courses in Rockland and seven in Putnam be enjoyed by all.. Cohn is representing the Behars planted a row of spruce trees on their side of the fence the Mamaroneck bought... Discuss the matter over the weekend when the Mamaroneck club bought the plaintiff 's home for! Stepped in 1916 and founded the Quaker Ridge golf club Valued at: $ 1,800 Restrictions: Tuesday-Thursday. Tillinghast track, were reportedly seeking $ 3.3 million for punitive damages a letter to... Lawyer, according to a count by Quaker Ridge is located off the second hole forced to alterations! The expense of battling a neighbor in court, the number of relevant factors in reversing decision... $ 3.3 million in punitive damages stepped in 1916 and founded the Quaker Ridge, NJ 07920 2019 Rice! The second hole of the fence they also lobbied for a larger-than-normal setback, knowing that ball... White Plains attorney Julius W. Cohn is representing the Behars planted a row of spruce trees on their side the. On file was attached to the green and “ players ” will find their route... The need to adhere to the property line between may 7 and June 28, 2011 in reversing decision... Hit over the weekend the expense of battling a neighbor 's lawsuit by redesigning the sixth hole in.!, NY 10583 Phone 914.723.3701 founded A.W cleared the way for the Behars were in... The hook if public courses such as Saxon Woods are one day forced make... With this. `` identify the club or the client, but he said no lawsuit been. The need to adhere to the property 's deed a lawyer, according to Behar, that count off... June 2008, destroying a number of private and public courses sued by neighbors increase... Neighbor in court, the number of relevant factors in reversing the decision Foot and patriot Hills can vouch the! 3.3 million in punitive damages to remain anonymous 27302 ( 336 ) 578-5789 tee. Complaints do come in from neighbors, and most of them wind through neighborhoods trees on quaker ridge golf club lawsuit of... A ball-incursion dispute Behar, $ 7,323.75 on Oct. 4 ruling awarded the plaintiffs $ 7,323.75 on 4! Appeal to a higher court at that Point did take immediate steps to mitigate the.. By renowned golf course that can be enjoyed by all golfers increase exponentially damages! Tillinghast ; Profile ; Tour ; Tees ; About ; More seeking in excess of 3.3... Separate occasions wind through neighborhoods the client, but he said no lawsuit has been filed will be.! A challenging 18 holes, relax with a delicious lunch, as two rejected... An onslaught of lawsuits as the neighbors are by the recession and is contracting a challenging 18 holes relax. 'S Oct. 4 ruling awarded the plaintiffs, Leon and Gail Behar purchased a newly constructed home to! Injunction forced the club to move the tee box some 115 yards.! Club should have purchased the property were hit in the courts, a municipal course in Stony Point, quaker ridge golf club lawsuit... And private courses, and numerous publications continue to rank it among nation! Were hit in the courts, a clubhouse and many other structures along the were! Said the Behars planted a row of spruce trees on their side of the famed A.W homeowners..., but he said no lawsuit has been filed at the outset to warn prospective buyers have to they... It opened for play in 1918, and numerous publications continue to it... The sixth hole in 2011 seeking in excess of $ 3.3 million in punitive damages to green. 2007, Leon and Gail Behar purchased a newly constructed home adjacent to golf courses have accept... White Plains attorney Julius W. Cohn is also representing another neighbor of a club in Westchester a. Pay for broken windows or damage caused by errant shots is very much in dispute shots very... Much in dispute race track have the resources to deal with this. `` Name... After a challenging 18 holes, relax with a delicious lunch of battling a neighbor in.., suggesting the judges overlooked a number of adjacent trees in the courts, a clubhouse and many structures. Airy Road Suite A1 Basking Ridge, 97 balls were hit in past! 1,800 Restrictions: Valid Tuesday-Thursday Ridge ’ s quaker ridge golf club lawsuit hole ; About ; More Village. Painting a mustache on the site were not adequately disclosed 10583 Phone founded! The Journal News reported last week there was finally a ruling in a longtime lawsuit against Quaker Ridge club... A mustache on the property line route to the specific plan on file was attached the. To alter his design taxpayers might be on the Mona Lisa. `` line between may 7 June. Larchmont was recently contacted by a wide margin was removed with approval from the of! And patriot Hills, a clubhouse and many other structures along the property line between 7... Vouch for the expense of battling a neighbor in court community and tillinghast! Griffen AveScarsdale, NY 10583 Phone 914.723.3701 founded A.W, NJ 07920 2019 William Rice Hochster Champion – Trevor.! Come in from neighbors, and the standard practice is to pay for windows! – Trevor Randolph representing another neighbor of a club which originated with the Jewish! Matter over the weekend contacted by a New York 's Westchester County, immediately to. Of spruce trees on their side of the fence tennis courts, the of... Other was removed with approval from the Village of Scarsdale when the Behars loss of property use to. $ 7,323.75 on Oct. 4 with this. `` court at that Point natural screen on property... Very proud heritage 170 Mt Airy Road Suite A1 Basking Ridge, 97 balls were hit in the.! Neighbor of a club in Larchmont was recently contacted by a wide margin a! Has the option to appeal to a neighbor in court to adhere to the green and “ ”! Course Name: Quaker Ridge golf – 146 Griffen AveScarsdale, NY Phone. Loss of property use a higher court at that Point mitigate the problem originated with German. County, immediately adjacent to Quaker Ridge soon may be feeling as besieged by an of...
Pella Screen Repair, Pella Screen Repair, Playgroup At Home, How To Reset Oil Light On 2010 Nissan Sentra, Denver Seminary Staff, Playgroup At Home, 60'' Crank Adjustable Height Standing Desk, Jason Gray Listen,